THE SWARM
An Eruption in the French Quarter
by Duncan Murrell
Harper's Magazine
August 2005
ON A MAY EVENING in New Orleans,
three days after Mother's Day, I
stand beneath a large live oak at the
corner of St. Peter and Decatur Streets
with two young men in T-shirts. One
fiddles with a barometric gauge and
wind meter while the other climbs up
an aluminum ladder, peering into the
main fork of the tree. Parents and children
wander past us on the sidewalk,
lugging bags and packages from the
Hard Rock Cafe and the Café du
Monde. Some stop briefly to ask us
about our work. Oh, they say.
The change happens so quickly and
with so little fuss that at first all I notice
is that the halo around the streetlamps
has atomized into floating, darting
pieces, hovering for a while before
falling to the ground. I am the last of
the three to realize what this means.
"Dude!" says the man who was on
the ladder, Dr. Matt Messenger. He
leaps over the cast-iron fence that encloses
the tree and heads up toward
the Riverwalk and the levee. "Oh,
man!" he calls, disappearing out of
sight. I follow the sound of his voice,
over the fence, through a low swampy
area riddled with bee's nests, up over
the next wall, until I'm standing in a
parking lot within sight of the dark,
silent river. Matt and I watch the termites
together.
They're in the air, flowing up over
the levee, emerging out of the darkness
from God knows where. They could
be coming from the railroad ties on
the line that runs parallel to the river's
edge, or they could be coming from
the planters that dot the Riverwalk.
They could even be coming from Algiers
on the other side of the river,
carried up and over the water by the
gentle, steady breeze. The winged
reproductives of Coptotermes formosanus
glide on, wherever they're
from, past the parking lot and through
the trees, over Decatur Street and
above the mules standing ready in harness
at the south end of Jackson
Square. They pass over the little park,
an airborne current of hundreds, each
periodically catching the light in its
translucent wings. At St. Louis Cathedral
the stream divides and twists to either
side, funneling into the space between
the Cathedral and the old
Creole town houses, accelerating up
Pere Antoine and Pirate's Alleys until
the termites disappear into the heart
of the French Quarter.
I return to the tree where the other
man, Aaron Mullins, a doctoral student,
has found an alate crawling on
his sleeve. I stand next to him and
watch as he lets the creature crawl
around his hand. I think I see an antenna
with an elongated flagellum waving
about, dark against the white of
Aaron's palm. The termite, satisfied
that it's found solid ground, reaches
back and rips off its wings, transforming
itself from a light-seeking winged
creature into a terrestrial suddenly desperate
for darkness and the companionship
of a mate. The four wings lie
in a pile on Aaron's thumb, each almost
twice as long as the insect and
nearly invisible except for their faint,
nut-brown color. The wings shudder
and flit about before they catch the
breeze and blow off into the dark.
Aaron lets the termite crawl from his
hand onto the sidewalk, and we watch
for a few minutes as it races in circles
looking for a companion. I notice that
another alate has landed in my hair,
and I let it crawl down my face until
I'm able to hold up my hand and let it
run along my knuckles and my palm.
When this termite also has reached
back and removed its wings, I set it
down near the first termite, and we
watch to see if they'll find each other,
but they just run in their separate circles until both disappear into the grass.
"Too bad," I say. Aaron simply walks
away to record more data.
In that moment, I know I have begun
to assign the termites the powers of
volition and desire, the experiences of
pain and regret. I am embarrassed by
this, and dare not mention it to the
scientists. The alates knock about trying
to find one another, a mostly futile
search that will end in failure and a
quick death for almost all. I have fallen
into the trap that captures so many
lay observers of the social insects, Hymenoptera
(ants, wasps, bees) and
Isoptera (termites), which is the easy
equation of sociality with culture, and
therefore humanity. In my unscientific
reverie, I imagine I am seeing not only
my own world mimicked and
mocked by an invertebrate but my own
body split and disassembled into cells,
exposed by proxy and revealed briefly
to the light. The termite swarm has inspired
an addled, credulous melancholy.
"Nature is an infinite sphere," Pascal
wrote, "whose center is everywhere
and whose circumference is nowhere."
I stand on the levee, wishing I had a
beer, and consider whether I'm just
another arrangement of matter, one
way of protecting and multiplying
genes, a mere collection of information.
I watch hundreds more termites
fly past the cathedral and momentarily
entertain the thought that they
could pass through me without my
noticing, like rain through a cloud.
Borges said that Pascal experienced
"vertigo, fright, and solitude" while
contemplating the physical world, and
why the hell wouldn't he? Borges also
pointed out that Pascal's metaphor of
the infinite sphere was once used by
the ancients to describe God.
My body is a mystery to me. It contains
too many moving and multiplying
parts working through processes I
barely understand and cannot see. I
fear this part of life, the unknown body,
the old bone sack. The cells of the
body are cryptic, until they fail or they
multiply so rapidly that organs begin to
shut down. I am afraid because they
are cryptic, which is also the word often
used in the scientific literature to
describe the most basic problem in the
study of subterranean termites: they
spend their lives underground, out of
sight, until once a year (in the case of
C. Formosanus) some of them burst
free and, no longer controlled by their
ancient queen, set off in flight seeking
their own mate and new foraging
grounds. Unbearably fecund, nature's
center breaks and cannot be contained.
It flutters toward the circumference,
toward the opposite sex and some
available wood, preferably soft.
Finally I rouse myself to go whooping
it up around the oak tree, chasing
alates from lamppost to lamppost with
the others. They are just insects. These
particular insects are evident in extremis,
they're invertebrates that annoy
and threaten and disrupt our illusion
of equilibrium, which is enough to
classify them as a pestilence, purveyors
of rot. The effort to kill off C. formosanus
in New Orleans, or at least to
control the overwhelming invasion, is
an effort to settle the question of who
owns the place, a deltaic crescent of
mud and sand and dirt at a bend near
the end of the Mississippi River. This
is a real struggle, not a figurative one.
And yet the alates part at St.
Louis's like water around a boulder,
and I think they are beautiful.
THERE IS ALLURE in the city's rot,
and not a few native authors have
bridged the short etymological gap between
decay and decadence, as if the
city's louche human history was written in the twisted, rotten, vinewrapped
beams of the old Creole cottages
of the French Quarter, the Victorian
shotguns in Fauborg Marigny,
and the rambling Queen Anne piles in
the Garden District and Uptown. The
city is wet, sunken, overgrown, and
tropical, and marks-in our imaginations
as well as on our maps-the dead
center of our country's underbelly. Of
course the city is the preferred home of
termites and wood mold and strippers
and drunks and obese hot-dog vendors
and moviegoers at odds with the
universe. Look in the eyes of the New
York television reporter making his
report from the Quarter-The bug that
ate New Orleans!-and you can see
the city as a frontier land of plagues,
oddities, and ghosts ruling over chaos.
I came to see the termite swarm.
Not because it's a typical, predictable,
and unremarkable peculiarity
of the city but because it is the opposite.
It is something extraordinary
that, if not for a relatively recent historical
accident, would not be a feature
of New Orleans life. Yet the invasion
also seems correct and proper.
It prompts wonder at all the other
historical accidents that have
shaped New Orleans, bestowing upon
it a unique culture, architecture,
art, and, above all, a certain reputation.
It raises the question of whether
something is an accident if it is of a
piece with all the other accidents.
The Formosan is an invader, an
alien, a resident of the city for only
the last fifty years or so, according to
the educated guesses of scientists and
pest-control operators. The termite
found its way to New Orleans and
flourished there by taking advantage
of what invasion biologists call "nonlinearities,"
or what the rest of us
might call the derangement and periodic
chaos of human settlement
and society.
THERE ARE SEVERAL reasons why
C. formosanus has had so much success
invading the French Quarter,
most of the city of New Orleans, and
great tracts of the Gulf Coast, moving
ever northward. They're able to
survive long trips across oceans in
dank cargo holds, or in the mulch of
a potted exotic plant, or in railroad
ties being moved across the country.
They'll attack live trees much more
often than do native termites, ruthlessly
seeking out wounds and other
openings in the trees' repellent
"live" layer, tunneling into the dead
center, establishing a colony, and
setting about the job of hollowing
out the whole thing. Unlike native
subterranean termites, they can
build their nests aboveground in the
rafters of old buildings, as long as
they have some access to water.
Their construction practices are unusual
among termites, especially
their hard, dense nests of carton material,
a combination of excrement,
masticated wood, saliva, and soil, divided
into a maze of tiny corridors
and cells. When they're separated
from a nearby water source, the termites
will forage for water, carry it
back in their crops, and deposit it in
the nest as if it were a giant sponge.
Otherwise the nest is their home,
which they ceaselessly expand.
Where the Formosans are foraging
-in the studs of a wall, for instance
-the carton sometimes takes
the shape of the very thing they're
eating. Pest-control operators in
New Orleans told me many of stories
of ripping out drywall to expose
what looked from a distance like
solid two-by-four framing pieces, only
to find that they were looking at
carton nests, the ghosts of a wall
long since consumed.
This is enough to distinguish the
Formosan from other termites, but
what most distinguishes C. formosanus
from the native subterranean termites
in Louisiana (the Eastern subterranean
termite, Reticulitermes flavipes,
and the dark southern subterranean
termite, Reticulitermes virginicus, to
name the two most common) is its
ability to reproduce. A good-sized,
mature, native subterranean colony
averages 200,000 to 500,000 individuals,
but a mature Formosan colony is
bigger by an order of magnitude-2 to
5 million individuals, and often many
more. In the mid-1990s the Algiers
Regional Library, across the
river from the French Quarter,
was infested with at least 60 million
termites, the largest known
colony of termites in the world.
Scientists suspect the colonies
that have invaded the French
Quarter dwarf those at the library.
In both cases, the Formosans
have carved out a niche in the ecosystem
not fully exploited by the native
species, which is a defining characteristic
of foreign species that aren't
merely "foreign" but also "invasive."
The Formosans, even with their
large colonies, have not crowded out
the native termites entirely; they just
exploit the full range of cellulose and
lignocellulose food sources with greater
persistence. Although they will compete
for the normal sources of food-
a house, a dead tree, an old rotted
boat-the Formosans also have found
food where the natives rarely bother to
look: in live trees, in the upper reaches
of tall buildings, in the paper insulation
in plastic-coated power cables,
in creosote-coated railroad ties and
telephone poles. The millions of Formosan
workers bring immense foraging
pressure to the areas around their
colonies, and they are not deterred by
what at first appears to be a fruitless
search. This has given rise to the myth
that Formosan termites will eat their
way through a concrete wall. What
they will do is sacrifice many thousands
of workers in an effort to find the
one imperfection in that wall, the one
circuitous passage formed by the tiniest
series of trapped air bubbles in an
isolated part of the concrete, and when
Termite #5,643,895 gets through and
discovers food, soon the whole colony
knows the way. Perfection is so
rare, and the Formosans so numerous,
that few man-made
structures can resist them.
THE SOURCE of this strength-in-numbers
strategy is the colony's queen, a
monstrous creature who lives at the
center of the colony, tended by a court
of workers, soldiers, and her king. The
colony is in her thrall-each worker,
soldier, nymph, and secondary reproductive.
All of them are the size and
color of a small piece of white rice.
They obey a series of dicta she issues in
the little-understood language of
pheromones and other chemicals
passed along by trophallaxis-food
sharing-and the termites' incessant
grooming of one another. In this way
she instructs some of the youngsters
to develop into soldiers, others into
workers, and a few others to transform
into alates who will eventually sprout
wings and, come May, take flight to
start their own colonies. She lives as
long as twenty years, sometimes longer.
She may have begun her colony during
a swarm years before, when she
was just a winged alate scurrying
around the ground, lucky enough to
find a mate and a good source of wood
in which to excavate a nuptial chamber,
also known as a copularium. If so,
she immediately began producing eggs
fertilized by her king, and sometime
during her first decade of life the colony
passed the one million mark, every
one of them her children. Around her
eighth year, she reached full sexual
maturity, what termitologists call her
physogastric state. Now she is
grotesquely huge, mostly a giant white
egg sack as long and thick as a person's
little finger. Her head and thorax
are tiny compared with the rest of her,
and she is unable to move or feed herself.
She can only issue orders and lay
eggs, as many as two thousand a day almost
every day of her long life.
The queen's longevity, her slithery,
wormy egg sack, and her unusual
lifestyle lead most who have seen a
queen to describe her alternately in
terms of awe and revulsion. While I
was in New Orleans, a pest-control
company sent word to the New Orleans
Mosquito & Termite Control
Board that it had dug up the center of
a Formosan nest and found a queen.
In digging up the colony, they had broken
the intricate web of communication
tying the colony together, and all
was mass confusion among the termites.
As they videotaped, it became apparent
that the termites didn't recognize
their queen anymore. Or maybe
they did, only with new eyes. Unable
to move, she was torn apart by
workers and even soldiers, who
rarely feed for themselves. She had
been one of the things of the dark,
her instincts, desires, and genetics
replicated hundreds of thousands
of times. When they could not be
controlled, she died. As a boy, I came
to know of such things in a recurring
bad dream, the only one
that has stuck with me.
EUGENE MARAIS, the depressive
South African naturalist and journalist
of the early twentieth century,
should be considered the first philosopher
of the termitary, a man who spent
much of his life puzzling out the dimensions
of the swarm and its meaning.
The termites he knew best were
the builders of giant, intricate mounds,
the various species of Macrotermes,
whose nests are often mistaken at a
distance for small huts, and collections
of them for villages. "We are ourselves
no more than dead termitaries, through
which circulates a living substance," he
wrote in The Soul of the White Ant
(1937), his classic work of obsessive
observation. This was not a benign
analogy for Marais; it was hardly an
analogy at all. Marais believed that
colonies of termites were distinct, compound
organisms not unlike the human
body, that every component from
queen to worker served a function not
just analogous but identical to the function
of our own hearts and livers and
brains and blood cells. Marais thought
that the termite colony lacked only
the power to move together as one organism,
and that someday they would
develop even that skill.
Although humans were nothing
more than dead termitaries, Marais was
not willing to saddle the termite with
the burden of being man's perfect
equivalent. Instead, he assigned the
termite a group soul, a "race memory"
shared by the colony, which dictated
the nature and organization of the termites'
lives, something that didn't require
individual cognition or individual
awareness of their world's
peculiarities. This seemed a blessing to
Marais, a lifelong drug addict who had
suffered terribly the death of his young
wife in childbirth. He later retreated
into the bush for years at a time, avoiding
humans in favor of baboons and
termites, and killed himself with a shotgun
in 1936.
It was individual awareness, especially
of nature, that frightened Marais
and drove him into morphine stupors.
He called it psyche. "For we seek in
vain in nature for love, sympathy, pity,
justice, altruism, protection of the innocent
and weak," he wrote. "If Nature
possesses a universal psyche, it is one far
above the common and most impelling
feelings of the human psyche. She certainly
has never wept in sympathy, nor
stretched a hand protectively over even
the most beautiful or innocent
of her creatures."
MY OWN PURSUIT of the swarm
took me up to the northern end of the
city, past the long narrow park between
West End and Pontchartrain
boulevards that was once the New
Basin Canal, dug by thousands of Irishmen
who were buried where they died
of yellow fever and malaria. Just past
the Celtic cross at the top of the park,
I turn right onto Robert E. Lee Boulevard,
past the Catholic girls of Mt.
Carmel Academy in their tartan and
white strolling into the road bearing
cell phones, and drive to the northeast
corner of City Park, where the USDA's
Agricultural Research Service
has its Southern Regional Research
Center. The main building, a classic of
the Federal Deco style of the 1930s, is
tall and looms over a broad green lawn
dotted with gardens and research plots.
I'm met at the door by an elfin man
in jeans and a billowing, white buttondown
shirt, all of it held together by a
large belt buckle in the shape of a scorpion.
He hands me his card, part of
which has been punched in the shape
of a termite. Dr. Weste Osbrink, research
entomologist.
"Got to sign you in," he says. "Terrorists."
He talks with his hands, and
the large set of keys he carries through
his belt loop jangles against his knife
pouch as we walk up to his laboratory.
On his door he's posted certificates testifying
to his daughter's prowess in the
martial art of tae kwon do. His laboratory,
at first glance, seems much more
like a garage or a wood shop than a
laboratory. Everything of value-his
books, his drills, the pieces of furniture
-has been marked with red spray
paint. There are ant farms here, piles of
Pest Control Technology Magazine there.
He has obviously practiced his lecture
on what scientists know about the
Formosan. He draws out the words he
wants to emphasize: colony coooooperation,
feeding presssssssure, chemical
resissssssstance. When I say something
he already knows, which
typically is every time I speak, he says
yup yup yup yup to keep the conversation
moving.
It turns out scientists know quite a
lot about the Formosan, but not nearly
as much as you would suppose would
be known about one of the most primitive
termites of an order that has survived
virtually unchanged since the
Cretaceous period, appearing more
than 100 million years before the first
hominids began loping around and
framing up houses. It's surprising to realize,
for instance, that scientists aren't
quite sure how sibling Formosans find
themselves branching off toward soldierhood
or workerhood, morphologies
so different it's hard to reconcile
that a soldier and a worker could share
the same two parents. They still puzzle
over the reasons some of the termites
in the colony switch developmental
paths. They're not sure why Formosans
prefer one type of wood over another,
or how they choose their mates, or how
exactly the various chemicals circulating
through their colonies control behavior,
or how far they can fly.
[There are more than 750,000 known species
of insects, and likely many millions more still
unidentified. Osbrink told me it isn't until an
insect insinuates itself into human society,
usually without welcome, that we begin to pay
attention. "The roots of entomology," he says,
"are in plague and pestilence."]
Osbrink has small starter colonies of
Formosans stored all over his laboratory.
While we stand cramped between
his lab bench and the bookshelf spraypainted
red, he searches around for
boxes of termites he wants to show
me, once opening up a cabinet and
pushing aside some old newspapers to
find a group of termites he had momentarily
misplaced. He pulls termites
out of buckets and off shelves and
throws them together in a rectangular
plastic tub to see if they'll kill one another
while we watch. They mostly
avoid contact, running madly in circles
searching for a way out.
When he cleans up, I notice that a
few have fallen to his bench. This worries
me, but Osbrink merely sweeps
the little workers onto the floor. "Oh,
they'll dry up in a day, no problem,"
Osbrink laughs. "Harmless." I had forgotten
that the termite needs water,
food, and a connection to its colony.
Absent those three, the termite is like
a leaf suddenly detached from its tree,
a useless and dying thing. The newest
advances in termitology-or, at least,
in the control of the Formosan-all
focus on this definitive characteristic
of the social insects, the essential need
of connection. The ARS building, I
discovered, was full of scientists looking
for ways to either break that connection
or take advantage of it.
I was tempted to ask Osbrink his
opinion of Marais's "group soul" theory,
but I knew it was too naive and antiscientific
to be of much interest to a
man pointing with a stick at maps of
the French Quarter like a colonel planning
an attack. He would not even say
whether he had any grudging admiration
for the insect and its adaptations.
It was not a question he asked himself.
The federal scientists are part of Operation
Full Stop, a joint federal, state,
and local project begun in 1998 to "develop
strategies and tools for suppressing
this unwanted invader," especially
in the French Quarter. It's Full Stop
that supports the ARS scientists and
their dozens of research projects, which
range from examinations of the termite's
aggressive behavior, to its taste
for certain woods, to the composition
and weaknesses of its gut fauna, to the
testing of certain antagonistic bacteria,
to the development of infrared detection
technology. At its heart, Operation
Full Stop embraces a concept of
pest control that had not been attempted
previously on a scale large
enough to eradicate termites. The project
takes an "area-wide" approach,
which assumes that it's not sufficient to
kill isolated groups of termites here and
there, especially when confronted by a
species enjoying such magnificent reproductive
success. You have to strike
at the center.
It's long been known that killing the
queen and would-be queens of a colony
is enough to eradicate the colony itself,
a practice more effective in places
where termites build mounds. But a giant
termite mound, unlike a hidden
Formosan colony, is an isolated and
obvious thing; it announces its presence.
The alate flight is one obvious
way of starting new colonies, but new
colonies of Formosans also can be
formed by a process of "budding,"
whereby a group from a mature colony
moves off and establishes a new, smaller
colony, with a new reproductive pair,
without ever breaking the surface and
revealing itself. In Armstrong Park researchers
have successfully killed off
large mature colonies, only to find later
that another group they hadn't
known existed had moved into the
dead colony's territory, often in a matter
of a few months.
In many ways, the eradication and
research program in the French
Quarter has all the characteristics of
a public-health project, requiring the
cooperation of all who live and own
property in the Quarter's 110 blocks,
frequent inspections, diagnosis, treatment,
and a public-education project.
It's as if the scientists are fighting
a chronic, communicable disease.
In the seven years they've been
counting in the research area, the
number of alates that take flight in
the spring has been reduced by 50
percent but no more. The program
has succeeded in the French Quarter
to an extent but there has been no
documented reduction in alates in
other areas of New Orleans. The
health of the Formosans elsewhere in
the city is mostly a mystery
until a house falls in.
ADRIAN DE PAUGER, the French
military engineer who laid out the
French Quarter in 1721, intended it to
be a regimented and easily defendable
grid of roughly 100 blocks, each divided
into twelve precisely drawn lots.
The Quarter is still laid out this way,
with some modification and expansion
over the years, yet it's anything but
regimented and uniform within the
edges of those blocks. Living cryptically
isn't just for termites in New Orleans.
The interior courtyards and
shaded loggia withhold multitudes.
I had been told that one of the reasons
the French Quarter was such a
perfect place for termites was because
the buildings were constructed in peculiar
ways, which made it simultaneously
easy for the termites to find
sanctuary and hard to be found.
Buildings and houses share walls, one
after the other, block by block, allowing
the termites to move from one
house to another at will. By order of
the Spanish cabildo, after the fires of
1788 and 1794 that destroyed much
of the Quarter, houses were supposed
to be built of brick or brick between
posts, and were supposed to have relatively
flat roofs. The flatter roofs,
on which water often collects, are
perfect landing strips for alates, complete
with all the necessities-wood,
moisture, secrecy. The brick-between-
post construction technique
is good for retarding fires, but the
beams themselves, which look like
bones pressed in among the flesh of
bricks, are convenient avenues for
termites. The bricks, made locally,
were high in sand content and therefore
retain moisture, another boon
to the termites. The fires also shifted
the architectural character from
French to something resembling a
Spanish tropical style. This meant
that exterior walls were often plastered
or stuccoed. To this day houses
that are built by the brick-betweenposts
method have to be stuccoed
according to the rules of the historic
district. Stucco is beautiful and historically
correct, but it can also trap
moisture against the walls and conceal
termite tunnels.
The weird intricacies of French
Quarter buildings are daunting to
the termite killer. Once I followed a
group of scientists as they hunted
termites in the apartments above a
restaurant on a well-known corner of
Decatur Street, where the night before
I'd watched Norway rats running
along the pipes that undergird
the galleries facing Jackson Square.
It was an old building, an old Creole
town house. We walked through the
dining room, through the kitchen
and the prep area, back out onto a
side street, and then back in through
a small door that took us up some
stairs past a number of rooms packed
full of junk but lit by fan transoms,
until we were up in the apartment
area, looking out through huge single-
story windows onto a patchwork
of roofs and empty spaces. It was
some time before I realized that I was
standing in what would have been
the loggia that lined an interior
courtyard, and that the courtyard itself
had been overrun by small commercial
buildings defined by a series
of narrow passageways and alleys
running this way and that.
We walked along the apartment level,
the scientists armed with infrared
detection devices and a microwave
motion detector, each trained on the
beams and facie boards and soffits that
crisscrossed the hallways and disappeared
into the apartments. We went
into the apartments, shouting, "Termite
control!" but found no termites.
"This is the best part of my job," one
of them said. "You get to see how
people live. You see everyone from
the rich to the poor, and
the vampires."
ONE MORNING I MEANDER over
much of the Quarter with three research
technicians, watching them
snatch sticky boards from the tops of
ninety-eight lampposts. On each of the
traps, termite alate and other insects lay
dead, captured in an array of final gestures:
legs flung out, wings detached,
heads strained forward. This is how
they keep track of the alate flights. One
of the techs tells a curious little girl
that they're collecting bogeymen.
The heat comes up as the morning
draws on, my glasses fog, and far
away down toward the river, up on
the roof of Lafitte's Blacksmith
Shop, a man rips apart a roof. The
shadows under the galleries are appealing,
and I step into one. I watch
the street and begin to notice how
many points of entry and egress the
sidewalks contain. There are innumerable
manhole covers, water-meter
covers, drain access points, and
brass caps marking the presence of
termite bait traps. I try to imagine
the underground world dug out by
the people of New Orleans, especially
the vast network of storm-water
drains that move great torrents of
water out of the city when it rains
(and there's no place for the water to
go in a city that's below sea level, a
good fifteen feet below the Mississippi
River at the bottom of Poydras
Street). The most noticeable thing
about the drive in from the Louis
Armstrong International Airport,
besides the acres of tombs contained
in the Metairie and Greenwood
cemeteries, is the massive new
pumping station along the side of
the road sprouting pipes a car could
drive through, each branching into
countless smaller pipes, and so on
until it's impossible to keep track of
where all the pipes go. Where once
there were canals there are now
streets, and possibly still more buried
bones of dead Irishmen. New Orleans
contains not just a figurative
underground but a real one
of unimaginable complexity.
IT IS HARD not to think we were
somehow built, or evolved, to disturb
and sculpt our surroundings to suit
us; if not, we must have lost our way
long ago, for disturbance is our art
and our main preoccupation. Had we
been an equilibratory species when
we rose up in Africa, we might never
have left. But what explains the essential,
peripatetic nature of human
life and culture, which through time
has developed a train of camp followers
of great length- invaders like us,
moving in our wake like gulls behind
a shrimp boat. Whatever the reason,
man has traveled the world, and continues
to travel the world at ever increasing
speeds. Was the arrival of
the mosquito Aedes aegypti, a foreign
invader thought to have traveled
aboard slave ships, divine punishment
for our mortal sin and meted
out in periodic epidemics of yellow
fever and dengue in New Orleans
and elsewhere? This is a tempting explanation,
but inevitability is more
likely the answer. If it hadn't been a
slave ship, it would have been a collector
of mosquitoes, or stowaways in
an around-the-world sailing race, or a
wet corner of an oil tanker. Inevitability
may itself be divine, but
what does it matter?
Those that follow behind us are
our pests, and we call them pests because
we believe they are the disturbers.
We willfully ignore that we
are ourselves berserkers, preferring to
believe in an illusory equilibrium of
national "characters," of cities with
"personalities," of sports teams with
"destinies," of individuals subsumed
in a fantasy of a collective mind that
is so very much more comforting
than the truth of our essential alienation.
This is what Marais knew, and
it is what drove him to the "group
soul" of the termites. The Norway
rat and the Yellow Fever mosquito
and the Formosan termite remind us
of our vulnerability, which we, the
naked ape, have worked
so hard to leave behind.
I'M STANDING on Prytania Street in
the Lower Garden District, counting
the strands of Mardi Gras beads
hanging like a kind of prismatic moss
from the trees, marking a trail that
winds away from me and over to St.
Charles Avenue, one of the main parade
venues for the krewes during
Mardis Gras. Around the corner the
men from the Norwegian Seamen's
Church are framing an addition entirely
out of concrete and steel,
which seems smart to me, now that I
see potential termite habitat everywhere.
I've been tapping on the walls
of the pleasant little guesthouse
where I've been staying, shaking the
wood stairways just a little and peering
behind the walls where the wallboard
has peeled away. This is how
easily a morbid fascination turns to
dread. I've begun to see things.
Ed Bordes, executive director of
the New Orleans Mosquito & Termite
Control Board, pulls up in his
old sedan. I hop in for a driving tour
through fifty years of termite history.
I am relieved to see him. This is the
man universally referred to as a
"good" and even "great" man by the
scientists I've met so far, even the
ones who don't work for him. I'm
calmed by him, by his neat, clipped
white beard, his sharp nose, his bulbshaped
head, his pristine white
sneakers, his pressed slacks and
white button-down shirt, and his giant
glasses. But then he says, "The
bottom line is I wouldn't be surprised
if the whole United States is infested,"
and I'm on edge again.
We drive toward the Industrial
Canal and then shoot up toward the
New Orleans Lakefront Airport on
Lake Pontchartrain. Later we'll end
up driving through the lakefront neighborhoods,
then down through
Metairie, then over Claiborne Avenue,
and eventually to Algiers, ending
up finally at his house up by the
lake again, having waved at the French
Quarter in passing. The experience is
very much like riding through the skirmish
sites on a battlefield.
The first Formosan termites likely
arrived sometime shortly after World
War II, when all the equipment and
matériel that had been shipped to
the Pacific theater made its way back
to the United States. New Orleans
was busy with military traffic, as it
had been since the opening of the
war. It's an educated guess that the
termites arrived at that time, based
on where the insect is native, what
ships were moving between there
and New Orleans, and where the earliest
and most virulent infestations
were first identified. Taken together,
everything points to the shipyards
along the Industrial Canal and the
military installations on Lake
Pontchartrain and on the Algiers
side of the Mississippi. After the war
these outfits began to get engines and
other equipment back from the Far
East, loaded in the Philippines or
Taiwan or Japan in wooden boxes,
stacked on wooden pallets, and
shored by tons of wood dunnage. Up
on the lake, where the Army had
built Camp Leroy Johnson on filled
land of just the right composition
and looseness preferred by subterranean
termites, the soldiers unloaded
boxes of forward-deployed
gear from countries where the Formosan
had been living for hundreds,
if not millions, of years. Down on the
river in Algiers, across from the
French Quarter, the Algiers Naval
Station was crowded with ship after
ship waiting their turn to rid themselves
of cargo.
The New Orleanians who repeatedly
described for me the short natural
history of the city's newest termite
did so in equal parts fascination, horror,
and pride. The pride was for the
wartime effort, and in their recitation
of the termite story it was often possible
to detect a sense of continuity, as
if the plague of termites was a part of
the sacrifice, a wound the city sustained
for the greater good.
But the French Quarter cannot be
allowed to suffer that wound. New
Orleans is no longer the important
port it once was, and it is no longer a
center of the American oil industry.
Many of the tall buildings in the
Central Business District are hotels
now, no longer offices for oil companies.
The tourism industry, with the
French Quarter at its center, is now
the city's second-biggest employer
and keeps growing as the oil-industry
jobs leach away. It is authenticity,
more than liquor and strippers and
music and voodoo, that is the French
Quarter's irreplaceable commodity,
and which must not be devoured.
And what of the rest of the city?
Bordes tells me the termite is changing
the city almost as dramatically as fire.
"What happens to poor people? That
doesn't work out." We drive along Claiborne
Avenue into the tough lower
Ninth Ward, once a 1,500-year-old cypress
swamp. Whether the poorest
neighborhoods of the city will be protected
from the termite, Bordes says,
will be a matter of will.
By the time certainty dawns, the
mating pair of C. formosanus has already
survived a months-long ocean
crossing from the Philippines in a
nuptial chamber gnawed from stray
wood. They've already been unloaded
from the ship. Fifty years later
you're drinking beers at a neighborhood
pub in the Irish Channel with
a professional shyster and a goth
stripper from Baton Rouge, listening
to her explain the technical aspects
of exorcisms, and all the while you're
wondering if the floor will soon collapse
in a shower of wood splinters
and carton nests.
Ghosts, I learn from the goth, who
appeased the dead family haunting
her club on Bourbon Street by
means of gifts and tough love, just
don't want to be alone.
They need people.
IN 1966, Ed King was a master's degree
student in entomology. That
year, Coptotermes formosanus had
been discovered both in New Orleans
and also out along a stretch of
the Calcasieu River near Lake
Charles, almost two hundred miles
away from New Orleans by interstate.
The discovery of these termites
occurred almost simultaneously with
discoveries in Houston (1965, eradicated;
rediscovered 1966), Galveston
(1966), and Charleston (1967).
Every one of the newly infested cities
hosted ports or airbases that received
war matériel back from the Pacific
theater years before.
King was "young and foolish
enough" to sign up for the kind of early
work demanded by an encounter
with a new species, the kind of very basic
essential fieldwork that asks, What
are you and what do you want? Decades
later, scientists studying C. formosanus
work up gene sequences through polymerase
chain reactions, but in 1966
what a young scientist like King most
needed was a shovel.
King's first Formosan paper, published
in 1968, described the 1.4-acre
maze of termite galleries-tunnels fortified
by carton material-that radiated
from the dead stump of a bald cypress
next to the Calcasieu River, two miles
from the town of Lake Charles. King
and his colleagues set about digging
around the stump where they'd found
a colony and then tracking each of the
hundreds of galleries that branched
from it, chasing each of them with a
shovel, and then a trowel, and then
scraping the final layer of soil and the
top of the tunnel away with a surgeon's
scalpel. In this way he mapped a significant
portion of the termite galleries,
along the way encountering the engineering
feats of the termites: their ability
to maintain steady levels of humidity
by digging some vertical tunnels
in strategic places and capping off others;
the inherent strength of their elliptical
galleries; their success at building
cemented sand lattices across the
ceilings like rafters ; and, finally, the
sheer complexity of the colony's byways
and the dense labyrinthine carton
nest of the main colony, the size of a
medicine ball once excavated.
Having studied the voracious invader,
why didn't King or anyone else
raise the alarm? It was the chemicals,
King explains. At the time, pest control
was largely a matter of picking out
which organochlorine would be most
effective: DDT, heptachlor, mirex,
chlordecone, and the preferred chemical
for termites, chlordane. In 1968
these chemicals had begun to gain a
bad reputation, and not only because of
Rachel Carson's Silent Spring, but it was
still a long time before they were all
banned. Chlordane wasn't banned for
all uses, including structural pest control,
until 1988, but it's clear that
people used existing supplies years after
the ban. For the homeowner the
two things that distinguished chlordane
as a pesticide was that it would
stay active in the ground for fifteen to
twenty years after treatment and that
it killed insects on contact. Chlordane
and its relatives could be injected into
the ground around the house to create
a poisonous moat not fordable by
termites. The chemical killed some of
the termites, but its most common effect
was to repel them. After that, it
didn't much matter where the termites
went, so long as they didn't get into
the house.
But the termites didn't go away, they
just went elsewhere. For decades in
New Orleans they grew, split off, migrated,
and grew some more, until
there were many millions, so many
that they could never be rousted out of
the city. All of this took place out of
sight. They found refuge in the city's
trees and power poles, in the cross ties
along the rail tracks that encircle and
divide the city, and in neighborhoods
where expensive pest control was the
least of one's worries. Researchers at
LSU kept an eye on the problem and
continued to study the termite
throughout the 1970s and 1980s, but
as long as there were effective, lethal
chemicals available, the Formosan didn't
concern many outside the small
termitology community. In fact, it's
questionable whether anyone, even
the scientists who knew the termite
well, could have predicted that the
termite would invade the rest of the
city so successfully once the chlordane
ran out. They're mysterious, people said
to me in explanation. It's hard to know
what they're doing.
In this case, the use of organochlorines
against termites-native and foreign
alike-was something like channeling
the course of a river. The water
never ceased, it had to go somewhere,
and when the dikes, seawalls, levees,
and locks finally failed, the effect of releasing
the water's long-contained energy
was catastrophic.
"You're trained as a scientist to deal
with nothing but the facts," said King,
who is now the director of the Agricultural
Research Service's Mid-South
Area, with responsibility for, among
many other things, the French Quarter
project. "Speculation is not encouraged,
particularly as a graduate
student. You don't have a foundation
to sponsor a visioning session. I had
put forth the hypothesis that the capability
was there for this termite to
spread as far north as Monroe,
Louisiana, but I thought because of
the cold temperatures north of there,
it wouldn't survive. I don't think that's
the case anymore. And as far as saying,
'Watch out, we're fixing to be infested,
and the French Quarter and all the
trees are in danger, and the [termiteinfested]
railroad ties are spreading
across the South,' I didn't do it. I
didn't see it."
In 1971, King couldn't find a job
studying C. formosanus, so he moved
on to other projects, other work. "You
put your money where the biggest problems
are, and because we had outstanding
chemicals, it was
not viewed as a big problem."
IN 1967 the state of Louisiana
banned the movement of wood and
wood products out of areas infested by
C. formosanus, a quarantine that in
theory would regulate the shipment of
railroad ties, which scientists believe
are largely responsible for the spread of
the Formosan around the Southeast.
Railroad ties aren't regulated, though,
because the spectacularly unsuccessful
quarantine was abandoned in 1990.
I found one office in New Orleans, a
branch of a national company, that
specializes in reclaiming railroad materials
and brokering their sale around
the country. They classify their railroad
ties by quality but will still sell
ties described this way: A fair to poor
quality tie for landscaping uses with a
minimum of one good solid side. Rot,
plate cutting and end splitting permissible.
"Rot" is one of those common words
that stand in for any violence done to
wood by mysterious forces emerging
from the dank and the dark, including
moulds and fungii and termites. To
say that a railroad tie has been rotted
is maddeningly unspecific, especially
when those ties come from New Orleans.
Railroad ties lend raw, natural
beauty to any landscaping project, the
company offers.
Raw, natural beauty. If we live in a
settled area of the United States, we
can look out our windows and see
what appears to be evidence of the
natural world. There are trees, and
birds, and green things growing, and
yet for most of us it's virtually impossible
to imagine the original landscape
before the streets, and the
houses, and the importation of thousands
of foreign ornamental plants.
What we see out our windows is usually
a simulacrum of the natural
world, this one shaped and in some
cases invented by man. There are
50,000 foreign species in North
America, and 400 of the 958 species
on the Endangered Species List are
threatened because of invasions by
foreigners. Outside my window, in
the woods around my small-town
cottage, I see English ivy, kudzu,
Japanese honeysuckle, bamboo grass,
and some stands of silk tree-all foreign
invaders, all introduced by man.
The English sparrows and the house
finches that dominate the other
birds at my feeder are both foreign to
this place-one from England, the
other from the Western United
States. I suppose a railroad tie infested
with Formosans is as raw and as
natural as most anything
else, relatively speaking.
THE NIGHT I SEE the big swarm begins
in a little neighborhood joint in
the Marigny that triples as a café, bar,
and grocery store. I watch the television
with some locals from the neighborhood
while having a beer. On the
television they're showing a martialarts
competition involving the breaking
of various building materials. The
men on either side of me turn out to be
experts in construction, and we spend
the better part of an hour exploring
the various ways the concrete blocks,
pieces of wood, bats, and metal pipes
could be fashioned to make them brittle
under the force of the chops, forearm
shivers, and elbow hammers dealt
by the crew of tattooed, roaring men
and women on the screen.
A tall, muscular Indian named Gary
tells me about his time working on a
project to determine the strengths of
various building materials, including
steel. He becomes animated describing
the beautiful way a rod of steel will
stretch into an hourglass shape, thread
thin, before suddenly ballooning at the
thinnest spot and snapping with a pop.
I tell him about a pair of termites that
built a colony on the top floor of one
of city's tallest buildings, a hotel, but
that doesn't interest him much. We
both agree that it's a little funny watching
people make sport of breaking wood
and concrete. You can make a sport of
anything, Gary says.
When I look out the window I realize
that the conditions are perfect
for a swarm. It's humid but not raining,
there's no wind, it's still kind of warm,
and the sun is going down. I leave to
drive by the various spots I know the
scientists will be waiting. I drive by
Matt Messenger and Aaron Mullins
at the corner of St. Peter and Decatur
sitting in folding chairs beside the old
live oak glowing beneath the JAX
Brewery sign. They're just talking, and
Matt has his hands behind his head.
I drive up and down the French
Quarter in my car, slowly rolling my
way through throngs of visitors walking
in the streets. I see some alates
here and there. I drive down Decatur
again, and there's a pretty good cloud
of alates at the streetlamp across from
Jackson Square. But I've seen bigger.
I turn back up toward the lake, go
right down Burgundy, then right
again down Gov. Nicholls, until I
encounter the largest swarm I've ever
seen. It's 8:10 P.M. at the corner of
Chartres and Gov. Nicholls. The
alates are clouding a streetlamp and
falling all over one another, tumbling
in little airy eddies down onto the car
below before taking wing again and
going for the light. I get out of my car
and feel the alates landing on me,
scrabbling along my neck and in my
hair. I watch them searching for each
other. I take pictures. A man passes
by, pushing his belly ahead of him.
"Are those termites?" he asks. "Yes,"
I say. Another woman comes striding
down the sidewalk, sees me covered
in termites, and crosses the
street. I can't see where they're coming
from precisely, but it appears
they could be coming over the wall
that borders the sidewalk and guards
a deep courtyard and some very old
trees. I stand watching for a while,
then I brush the termites off and get
back into the car.
I almost head home, but then I
decide to drive out of the Quarter, a
place I'm suddenly tired of thinking
about. I drive out to Canal and take
a right headed away from the river.
On my left is the median of the big
boulevard, which I remind myself is
called neutral ground by locals, a
holdover from the time when Canal
was the divide between the French
and American sections of the city,
back when the French were the city
and everybody else was anarriviste,
an unwelcome invader.
Farther along Canal I start to see
larger clouds of alates flitting in the
light of the tall lamps arrayed on the
neutral ground. I drive up to Rampart,
which marks the northern border
of the Quarter, and turn right.
Off to my left I see a monstrous, pulsating
swarm and realize what I'd
seen back in the Quarter was only a
minor eruption.
They appear in the sky below the
very tall streetlamps as a long, kinetic
cloud of white. Alates fly to the
light from both sides of the street to
join one another. They come from
the stores on my right, from the
Iberville housing project on my left,
from all over. I've never seen anything
like it, which I suppose is a testament
to the ingenuity of the scientists
and their partners. Instead of
congratulating them, I want to rush
back to the oak under the JAX
Brewery sign and tell Matt and
Aaron that the termites are everywhere,
but I know that they already
know this.
I can't stop my car very easily, so I
end up driving around Rampart and
over to Armstrong Park and back
again, over and over, watching the
swarm expand. I follow clouds of flying
insects into Tremé, one of the
nation's oldest historically black
neighborhoods, and I find that I am
driving on Marais Street, a coincidence
so stupendous I begin yammering
to myself and scribbling
notes on the back of my hand as I
drive. I realize I'm driving dangerously,
so I pull over under a power
line that crosses the street and watch
a skinny rat run along the wire from
one side of the street to the other.
Two little girls from the neighborhood
walk past me on the sidewalk,
each gently picking termites out of
the other's hair.
Finally, I go to my room and pull
out Marais's little book to read its
odd ending again. He had spent
years on the veld observing termites,
but never once had he seen a queen
in her chamber. He'd finished publishing
his little articles on termites
when he was called to Pretoria to see
a house completely infested and realized
he had been handed a rare opportunity.
He struck a deal with the
workmen tearing apart the house in
search of the queen: he would point
out the "palace cavity" to the workmen
only if they let him watch the
queen, unmolested, for two to three
days. They agreed, and finally Marais
had his chance to observe the brain
of the compound organism, the termitary,
which was blessed with a
group soul and not with the almost
unbearable burden of individual consciousness,
which was man's, and
certainly Marais's, curse.
He saw much more than he ever
expected to see. He came to understand
things he had not understood,
and certain mysteries were revealed
to him that he had not known existed.
Then he watched as a piece of
clay dislodged by the excavations fell
and hit the queen, causing her to
move her head back and forth in a
strange way. The workers who had
been tending her began wandering
aimlessly, and elsewhere in the
colony all work ceased. Then her
bodyguards disappeared and a rush of
workers set upon her and began to
suck the fluid from her, devouring
her body. Even her king joined in
the feast. Soon she was emptied, her
skin "hanging in loose folds," but she
was not dead.
They turned on her perhaps out
of confusion, a disruption in the
linkage that formed what Marais
called the soul and what scientists
today would describe as an elaborate
system of chemical communication.
Perhaps. But as quickly as they
turned on her, they stopped and began
to nurture her back to health.
The next day, the colony went
about its business as if nothing had
happened. It was a wonderful and
puzzling event, and as it is with all
moments of wonder, it couldn't last
long. "And that was the end of our
observations. The workmen had occupied
themselves with excavating
and removing the breeding gardens
in other rooms, but now the time allotted
to us had come to an end.
The queen was removed from her
half-cell and taken away captive;
and after that the activities and life
of this nest ceased for good."
It was just one queen. There were
others; there had always been others,
and there will always be more. It's
silly if not impossible to grieve for a
termite. Grief is for other things,
things that don't persist.
Copyright © 2005 Duncan Murrell
Back to Writing
